Mind reading: a cognitive distortion

Examples of mind reading

Nobody has said a word, yet the verdict feels certain. Mind reading fills a gap in information with a guess about another person’s head, and, often, the guess is about you. The skill to practise is noticing exactly where what you saw ends and what you supplied begins.

The examples below are made up, to show the pattern.

  • At work

    Your manager walks past your desk without saying good morning. She hasn’t mentioned your report.

    “She’s annoyed about my report and is working out how to tell me.”

    More balanced: She walked past without saying good morning. I don’t know why, and she hasn’t said anything about the report.

  • In a relationship

    Your partner is quiet all through dinner.

    “He’s bored of me and wishes he were somewhere else.”

    More balanced: He’s quiet tonight. I could ask how his day went instead of filling in the answer.

  • About yourself

    At eleven at night, one person yawns while you’re telling a story at a party. The others keep listening.

    “Everyone here thinks I’m dull.”

    More balanced: One person yawned, late at night, and the others kept listening. A yawn doesn’t tell me what the room thinks.

How to catch mind reading

When the thought shows up, put these to it, ideally in writing:

  • What did this person actually say or do, word for word?
  • Am I filling a silence with the words I fear most?
  • If I asked them straight out, what are three different answers they might give?
  • Would I bet money that I know what is going on in their head?

Try it on a thought

Does it contain this trap?

Not a positive spin: what you would say if you stuck to what you know.

Check it against every trap

Questions people ask

Is mind reading the same as reading the room?

One way to tell them apart: can you point to something they said or did that shows what they think? If you can’t, treat your conclusion as a guess and keep it open to being wrong.

Should I just ask the person?

Asking is one way out: a light “Everything okay?” is enough. If asking isn’t possible, write the guess down and mark it clearly as a guess.

A calmer mind, in your pocket

We're building a companion app for anxious, looping thoughts. It isn't out yet. Leave your email to hear when it launches.